Blades vs Rack Servers For vSphere

blade chassis vs rack servers

Blades Are Sexy!

Are you trying to decide whether to use blade and chassis instead of rack mounted servers for virtualization? Here are the Pros and Cons of Blades vs Rack Servers…

Pros of Blade and Chassis for VMware vSphere

  • First of all Blade and Chassis are Cool, especially UCS! (now that we have that out-of-the-way lets move on).
  • Uses less network ports (2 or 4 per chassis depending storage type)
  • Uses less power.
  • Uses less cabling.
  • Creates less heat.
  • Uses less rack space (Approx. 10U for 16 blades).
  • Uses less rack space and square footage for higher density DC.
  • Centralized server management.

Cons of Blade and Chassis

  • Cool is more expensive. (1 Chassis, 16 blades and networking Approx. $300K)
  • Higher density means a larger failure domain (Approx. 350 VMs in 1 fully populated chassis would require 2 (3 would be better) more fully populated chassis running at 35 – 70% utilized. Remember when you maintenance these chassi, the VMs need to be vMotioned somewhere or powered off.
  • Huge hassle when doing firmware upgrades of chassis, blades and other chassi components.
  • Networking and storage configuration can get tricky requiring training staff.

 Pros of Rack Mounted Servers for vSphere

  • Per server is cheaper (2 socket, 24 core, 192 GB memory – Approx. $16K).
  • Smaller failure domain is easier to evacuate 1 host server (25- 30 VMs) if something fails.
  • Nothing new for DC staff to learn (easy setup).
  • Easy firmware and driver upgrades.

Cons for Rack Mounted Servers

  • Uses more network ports.
  • Uses more power.
  • Requires more cabling (copper/fiber).
  • Causes more heat (high cooling bill).
  • Uses more rack space (2 – 4U per server).
  • Lower density per square foot of DC.
  • Individually managed servers (more IPs).

Blades vs Rack Server Conclusion:

First let me apologize to all my friends at Dell and HP, but I need to be honest here. There’s obvious a sales benefit to blade and chassis over rack mounted servers and that’s why many sales reps will push them.

If blade and chassis are already an established hardware standard then it’s a no-brainer to stick with the standard, however, if you are being sold blade and chassis right out of the gate and your IT operation is smaller than 1000 VM servers consider that HA will require spanning blade servers across 2 – 4 chassis. This is the main reason why rack servers may be the better solution.

Rack mounted servers aren’t sexy but they’re much easier to scale capacity at a lower cost.

It can be frustrating when you’ve purchased your first two chassis with 4 blades per chassis, and then later on finding out the blade server technology has changed and now requires you to purchase upgrades for the chassis in order to use new generation blades. This is a real world example and is an important fact to consider…

Here’s my simple formula:

  • 1500 VMs or more – blade servers are the better solution and remember to plan for multiple failure domains, maintenance mode and upgrades.
  • 1000 VMs or less – rack mounted servers are a better solution and remember to build enough extra capacity into your environment to allow a host to be evacuated.

Your turn – share input on Blades vs Rack Mounted Servers For VSphere!

Discussion

Leave a Reply

vSphere Data Protection EOA
3 Alternative vSphere Backup Replacements For VDP

Important Notification: vSphere Data Protection (VDP) End of Availability (EOA) That...

vSphere 6
8 Updates That Make vSphere 6 Better – Keith Barker

Editor’s note: Keith Barker has been a CBT Nuggets Trainer since 2012. Some...

VMware Interview Questions
25 VMware Interview Questions And Answers: Tough & Technical (Download PDF)

Free VMware vSphere Interview Guide In this VMinstall Guide I’ll share a...

Project Photon
VMware Project Photon: Technical Review for Linux Admins

My quick and dirty review of Project Photon. I was very happy...

DevOps Plan
Best DevOps Strategy Hack (Winners Start With Why)

What is DevOps? It’s a model. It’s a culture. It’s a...

DevOps Tools Download
DevOps Toolchain: Download 3 Free Tools Used By Pros (Ansible, Git, Jenkins)

Hack Your Resume with DevOps Skills Lately I’ve been getting a...

DevOps Guide
Microsoft DevOps: 25+ Powerful Windows SysAdmin Skills (NEW Guide!)

What is Microsoft DevOps? This is an interesting question because first off,...

continuous integration tools
DevOps Training Courses That Will Give You The Edge (Perfect For Beginners Who Want Skills That Are Noticed By Google & Facebook…)

When I was just a fledgling starting out as a Jr...

Click here to learn how to Optimize WordPress Speed
WordPress Speed Optimization: Part 4 – VPS Case Study To Make VMinstall.com Rank Higher In Google Through Faster Hosting & High Availability @ Lower Cost

This is going to be a quick and dirty part 4...

Best Hosting for WordPress
Case Study: Best VPS For Easy WordPress Migration

Why I moved my WordPress blog off slow shared hosting… Let’s...

cloudways review updated
11 Cloudways Review Pros & Cons From My Deep Dive Testing (VPS Series: Part 2)

Which is a better cPanel alternative of a VPS – Cloudways...

ServerPilot Review
ServerPilot Review: Installing WordPress On DigitalOcean (VPS Series: Part 1)

How to install WordPress on a cloud server like a Pro...

DesTechAZ
What’s So Interesting About Woz U?

On 10/12/2017, I had the privilege of attending the AZ Tech...

tensorflow training
TensorFlow Tools for Beginners (7 Easy Takeaways To Get You Started)

Introduction To Deep Learning As a follow-up to my book review...

job rut
How To Get MOVING When You’re Stuck In A Career Rut (Video)

You worked hard to get your degree and after graduation you...

Storage Engineer Skills
Why Storage Engineer Skills Are HOT! (Can You Say Big Data?)

3 BIG Skills New Storage Engineers Are Missing Out On… Behind...

Open Source Storage Software
3 Open Source Storage Software Alternatives For Beginners

Build Your Own Storage Solution! Reflecting on my trip to VMworld...

VMware VCP FOR Hire eBook
Read Excerpts from VCP for Hire eBook

BIG Thanks… Before I share the excerpt of VCP for Hire,...

How to Self Publish Your VMware eBook KDP
How to Self Publish Your VMware eBook KDP

Do you have a VMware book you’d like to self publish...

free chef for 5 servers
Free Hosted Opscode to Try Chef On 5 Servers Before You Buy

Is Chef the configuration management and automation tool for your operations team?...